Commercial sexual exploitation
If you have been involved of prostitution or commercially sexually exploited you may have experienced sexual violence many times. If you feel you are ready to talk we are here to offer you support and information free from judgement, whether or not it is in the past or happening now.
WRASAC recognises that those involved in prostitution are often at high risk of sexual violence. The law in Scotland is absolutely clear – rape and sexual violence carried out in the context of prostitution is a criminal offence, and all survivors are entitled to exactly the same justice and support. There have been a number of successful prosecutions in Scotland in recent years of cases involving sexual violence against women in this context, and we have supported many women, including trans women, involved in prostitution who have been raped and sexually assaulted.
We have a dedicated support service for women, including trans women, involved in or at risk of prostitution called Vice Versa – you can also be referred to them for support if you wish. Vice Versa is a partnership project delivered by Women’s Rape and Sexual Abuse Centre (WRASAC) and CAIR Scotland. Together we bring a range of specialist support services to you aimed at increasing your safety whilst involved in prostitution and supporting you to find routes out of prostitution if this is something you wish to do.
Vice Versa works closely with WRASAC, CAIR Scotland, Community Safety Wardens, Dundee Violence Against Women, Tayside Substance Misuse Services, NHS Sexual Health and Reproduction Services, Tayside Police and the Alcohol and Drugs Partnership.
What is commercial sexual exploitation?
A special thanks to the Women’s Support Project for their help in writing this section
There is no fixed definition of commercial sexual exploitation (CSE), but a useful definition is:
“Sexual exploitation is a practice by which person(s) achieve sexual gratification, or financial gain, or advancement through the abuse of a person’s sexuality by abrogating that person’s human right to dignity, equality, autonomy, and physical and mental well-being.”
It includes sexual activities such as prostitution, phone sex, stripping, internet sex/chat rooms, pole dancing, lap dancing, peep shows, pornography, trafficking, sex tourism and mail order brides. Sexual
Exploitation includes offering drugs, food, shelter, protection, other basics of life, and/or money in exchange for sex or sexual acts.
It includes prostitution, stripping and lap-dancing, pornography and sex trafficking, as well as innumerable variants from sex-chat lines to mail order brides. CSE is included in both Scottish Government and United Nations definitions of violence against women based on the physical and mental harms suffered by victims and its roots in and impact on gender inequality. These harms stretch from difficulty entering other forms of work to increased likelihood of drug and alcohol abuse, difficulty with relationships, mental health issues including post-traumatic stress disorder, physical and mental abuse, rape, assault, and increased mortality rates. The Scottish Government definition of CSE notes that it is harmful “irrespective of whether individual women claim success or empowerment from the activity”.
It is our view that commercial sexual exploitation is inextricably linked with both the prevalence and the acceptability of sexual violence within our society. Any work towards gender equality and the elimination of male violence against women is undermined so long as the abuse of women and children through commercial sexual exploitation goes unchallenged. The objective of work around sexual violence must be the eradication of rape and this will not be achieved until we tackle the root causes of this violence – namely structural inequality, negative attitudes to women and society’s tolerance and acceptance of these attitudes.
Commercial sexual exploitation commodifies women and girls and supports a culture that views women as objects who are more a ‘sum of body parts’ than a whole being, and eroticises men’s violence and their perceived ‘right to buy’ whatever acts they have sexualised.
Whilst sexual exploitation mainly involves the abuse of women and girls, men and boys are also affected. Firstly some men and boys are directly abused and exploited through prostitution and pornography, overwhelmingly for use by men. Secondly men are financially exploited by the sex industry – they are paying to access something that should be free, equal and respectful. Whilst the vast majority of men who buy sex are in a position to choose – unlike the women and children who are prostituted – nevertheless we are concerned at the normalisation of the sex industry and the pressure on men, especially young men, to be consumers within the sex industry.
- 89% of scenes in the most popular pornographic videos in the US contained either verbal or physical aggression. 94% was directed at women. 1
- 58% of UK 12-15 year olds surveyed had viewed pornography online. 2
- 63% of teenage girls surveyed would rather be glamour models than doctors, nurses or teachers. A quarter thought being a lap dancer would be a good profession. 3
- Scottish research with 110 men who had bought sex found that 31% of the men had accessed prostitution through a lap dancing club. 4
- In the three years after four lap-dancing clubs were opened in Camden incidents of rape reported by local women increased by 50%. 5
- Research consistently shows that up to three quarters of women in prostitution in the UK began their involvement aged under 18, and around a quarter between the ages of 13 and 16. 6
- 63% of women in prostitution in an international study had been raped; 68% met the criterion for post-traumatic stress disorder. 7
- Nine out of ten women in prostitution surveyed would like to exit but feel unable to do so. 8
Money and Power: Commercial Sexual Exploitation in Scotland
1 Robert Wosnitzer et al (2008), Mapping the Pornographic Text: Content Analysis Research in Popular Pornography
2 Sonia Livingstone, magdelena Bober (2004), UK Children go Online: Surveying the Experiences of Children and their Parents http://eprints.lse.ac.uk/395/1/UKCGOsurveyreport.pdf
3 www.thelab.tv survey of nearly 1000 girls – see http://menmedia.co.uk/manchestereveningnews/news/s/161338_naked_ambition_rubs_off_on_teen_girls
4 Jan McLeod et al (2008), Challenging men’s Demand for Prostitution in Scotland, Women’s Support Project http://www.vawpreventionscotland.org.uk/sites/default/files/ChallengingDemandScotland.pdf
5 Eden (2003), Lapdancing and Strip Tease in the Borough of Camden http://www.childtrafficking.com/Docs/poppy_03_lap_dancing_0109.pdf
6 Home Office (2004), Drug Problems and Street Sex Markets: Solutions and Strategies http://www.vawpreventionscotland.org.uk/sites/default/files/Drug%20Problems%20and%20Street%20Sex%20Markets.pdf
7 Melissa Farley et al (2003), Prostitution in Nine Countries: An Update on Violence and Post Traumatic Stress Disorder, Haworth Press http://www.vawpreventionscotland.org.uk/resources/research-and-reports/prostitution-nine-countries-update-violence-and-post-traumatic-stre-0
8 Melissa Farley et al (2003) – ibid
In this section
- Reporting to the police and court process
- Adult survivors of childhood sexual abuse
- Ritual abuse
- Commercial sexual exploitation
- Information for family and friends
- LGBTI survivors
- Sexual abuse against boys and men
- Survivors' stories
Dundee and Angus Young Survivors
We support survivors of all genders aged 11 to 18.
Make a donation
We need your support to maintain our service.